Grace Cathedral Grace Cathedral
Home Archives
Our Church Shop
Audio & Video Support Us
Labyrinth Contact
Enrichment About Us
Calendar

Play the Ball Where the Monkey Drops It

 

Excerpted from Play the Ball Where the Monkey Drops It: Why We Suffer and How We Can Hope. (c) 2001 by Gregory Knox Jones. Reprinted with permission of HarperSanFrancisco. All rights reserved.

Buy the book from Amazon.com and help support GraceOnline.


"I need a huge favor," were the first words out of Judy's mouth when I answered the telephone. "Some friends of mine desperately need a minister."

 Her friends, a twenty-something couple, were experiencing every parent's dreaded nightmare. Their seven-month-old child had died and Judy was calling to ask if I could do the funeral.

 

Three days later a stark image was etched into my mind forever. It was the sight of these young parents carrying a tiny white casket to a cavity in the earth. They appeared catatonic as they trudged through the frozen grass, carrying their precious child for the final time. Their feet were heavy, each step more arduous than the last, and they kept wishing they would awaken from a sleepy stupor to discover it was all a horrible dream. But this was no mere nightmare. Their infant son was dead and they struggled to understand why this overwhelming tragedy had struck them. As I said the final prayer and benediction, the young mother and father filled the silence with deep moans. They felt as if a nuclear device had been detonated in their souls. The devastation was massive and they struggled to make sense of their catastrophe. Had they done something wrong? Were they being punished for some offense? They pleaded with me for answers.

 

If God is good, then why do innocent children die? All people of faith must answer this question, and the way we answer has far-reaching implications. Our solution of this dilemma satisfies more than mere intellectual curiosity. It determines what we believe about God's involvement in our lives and what basis we have for hope. Thus it strongly influences the course our lives take.

For many years I struggled with this troublesome question. What I had been taught to believe about God simply did not square with the profound suffering experienced by my parishioners (not to mention such monstrous evils as the Holocaust). Time and again the members of my congregation would ask me why they suffered devastating losses and told me they would continue to hound me if I replied with simplistic responses such as, "We have to trust that God has a reason." My people sensed what I had been thinking for some time--some of the traditional religious answers are no longer satisfactory.

As a pastor who has served in the parish for more than twenty years, I have been summoned to console families struggling with the loss of loved ones from cancer, suicide, and sudden accidents. I have buried young children, college students on the verge of graduation, and people in the prime of their lives. Over time, the traditional answers to unjust suffering proved to be inadequate. A fresh understanding of God gradually evolved as I faced real life tragedies and kept asking, Why would God allow this to happen? Call it an internal struggle that would not abate or call it a religious quest I could not avoid, I had no alternative but to revise my ideas about God.

They felt as if a nuclear device had been detonated in their souls.

 

It took several years, but the answers began to take shape. As I shared them with members of my congregation, they responded with enthusiasm. Many said that for the first time they understood why devastating blows could strike anyone. Even better, they were recovering a stronger sense of hope.

My answers are contained within the covers of this book, and they are for everyone whose life has been (or will be) touched by grief--which is to say all of us. I have tried to avoid using abstract language and complex explanations, but that is not to imply that the answers are always easy to embrace. Real answers to the difficult dilemmas of life are not always easy to adopt. My prayer is that what I have written will help you understand why suffering is so prevalent in our world, and how--despite its presence--you can live a genuinely hopeful life.

Chapter One:

Play the Ball Where the Monkey Drops It

The story is told of a golf course in India. Apparently, once the English had colonized the country and established their businesses, they yearned for recreation and decided to build a golf course in Calcutta. Golf in Calcutta presented a unique obstacle. Monkeys would drop out of the trees, scurry across the course, and seize the golf balls. The monkeys would play with the balls, tossing them here and there.

My people sensed what I had been thinking for some time--some of the traditional religious answers are no longer satisfactory.

At first, the golfers tried to control the monkeys. Their first strategy was to build high fences around the fairways and greens. This approach, which seemed initially to hold much promise, was abandoned when the golfers discovered that a fence is no challenge to an ambitious monkey. Next, the golfers tried luring the monkeys away from the course. But the monkeys found nothing as amusing as watching humans go wild whenever their little white balls were disturbed. In desperation, the British began trapping the monkeys. But for every monkey they carted off, another would appear. Finally, the golfers gave in to reality and developed a rather novel ground rule: Play the ball where the monkey drops it.

As you can imagine, playing this unique way could be maddening. A beautiful drive down the center of the fairway might be picked up by a monkey and then dropped in the rough. Or the opposite could happen. A hook or slice that had produced a miserable lie might be flung onto the fairway. It did not take long before the golfers realized that golf on this particular course was very similar to our experience of life. There are good breaks, and there are bad breaks. We cannot entirely control the outcome of the game. .

 

Related Links

Coping With Stress And Anxiety
What can you do to bring your life into balance? Counselor and author David Kundtz and the Rev. Dr. Lauren Artress discuss the challenges of maintaining emotional and spiritual health in this fast-paced world while offering concrete steps to reduce stress in your life. Forum.

Golf and The Game of Life
Anne Kishman Fisher talks about the intensely spiritual experience of golf. Golf is a living, working metaphor for the reality of experience. Interview.

Good Grief, Bring Me Relief!
Find out how to cope with the effects of depressions and how to prevent it in the future. Forum.